“Always Open With” not working on Mac: why, and the fix
You right-click a file, hold Option, choose Always Open With, and the next file of the same kind opens in the old app anyway. This is the most common confusion about defaults on a Mac, and it is usually not a bug.
1. “Always Open With” only changes that one file
The Option-key menu sets a default for the single file you clicked. Other files of the same type are untouched. To change the type, select a file, press ⌘I, pick the app under Open with, and click Change All….
2. You chose the app but didn't click Change All
Picking an app in the Get Info window also applies to that one file until you click Change All… and confirm.
3. You dismissed the confirmation
Since macOS 26.4, Finder asks you to confirm before a file-type default changes, with buttons to use the new app or keep the old one. Closing the dialog, or pressing Return on the wrong button, leaves the old default in place.
4. The file has its own setting, which wins
If you once used Always Open With on a particular file, that file remembers its own app and ignores the type's default. Open Get Info for that file and choose the app you want. Files copied from another Mac can carry such a setting with them.
5. The extension isn't what you think
.jpeg and .jpg are one type, but .doc and .docx, or .mp4 and .mkv, are different types with different defaults. Check the exact extension under Name & Extension in Get Info. A file with no extension has no type to set.
6. Another app changed it back
Some apps claim file types again when they update. If a default changes a few days after you set it, that is the cause: see the guide below.
Manage every default in one place
Defaultify for Mac shows all your file-type and link defaults in one window, flags missing ones, and with Pro warns you when an app takes one over.